As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Privacy Policy / Terms
The world of eBay is a digital Wild West, where the weird and wonderful find new homes through the power of online auctions. While some people use it to buy practical items like shoes or phone chargers, others go hunting for something… stranger. Over the years, eBay has been the site of some of the most bizarre transactions ever recorded. From celebrity leftovers to paranormal oddities, here’s a look at the strangest items ever sold on eBay.
1. The Virgin Mary Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Back in 2004, a Florida woman named Diana Duyser changed the online auction game forever when she sold a grilled cheese sandwich that she claimed bore the image of the Virgin Mary. Even more bizarre, the sandwich was ten years old at the time of sale—yet mysteriously free of mold. Whether it was divine intervention or just good preservatives, the holy toast fetched a staggering $28,000 from an online casino that apparently had money to burn.
2. Justin Timberlake’s Half-Eaten French Toast
Ever wondered what it would cost to eat like a pop star—literally? In 2000, a New York radio station got its hands on a piece of French toast that had once belonged to Justin Timberlake. They promptly put it up for auction, and a superfan paid $1,025 to own JT’s leftovers. What they did with it afterward? That remains a mystery.
3. A Ghost in a Jar
In one of eBay’s spookiest sales, a seller auctioned off what they claimed was a ghost trapped inside a jar. The seller warned that ever since finding the jar in a cemetery, strange things had been happening to them. Naturally, they wanted to get rid of it, and lucky for them, someone was willing to pay thousands of dollars for it—before eBay shut the listing down for violating policies on intangible goods.
4. The Meaning of Life
For those suffering from existential crises, one eBay seller attempted to solve the biggest question of all time by listing “The Meaning of Life” for sale. The listing attracted curious bidders, though it’s unclear what the winning bidder actually received. A handwritten note? A deep philosophical conversation? Or just a blank stare through the internet?
5. A Cornflake Shaped Like Illinois
What’s better than breakfast? Breakfast that resembles a U.S. state. In 2008, two sisters from Virginia discovered a cornflake that looked exactly like the state of Illinois and decided that someone, somewhere, would want to buy it. They were right—someone shelled out $1,350 for the geographically significant flake.
6. Britney Spears’ Chewing Gum
Chewed-up gum usually goes straight into the trash, but when it’s been in Britney Spears’ mouth, it becomes a collector’s item. A piece of gum supposedly discarded by the pop star went up for sale, and dedicated fans eagerly placed bids in hopes of owning a memento of their idol—DNA and all.
7. A Haunted Rubber Duck
Toys aren’t always fun and games. One eBay seller put up a listing for a supposedly haunted rubber duck, claiming it was responsible for eerie occurrences and bad luck. Despite the unsettling description, someone willingly paid over $100 to take the duck off their hands. Hopefully, it didn’t cause any bath-time hauntings.
8. A Potato Chip Shaped Like Jay Leno
Celebrity look-alikes exist in Hollywood, but what about in snack form? Someone stumbled upon a potato chip that bore a striking resemblance to Jay Leno and decided to sell it online. Though the final selling price remains unknown, the fact that people were interested proves that you should always check your chips before you eat them.
9. The Original Hollywood Sign
The original Hollywood Sign, built in 1923, was replaced in 1978. But instead of tossing it away, someone decided to put it up for sale on eBay. A collector of Hollywood memorabilia snatched it up for a cool $450,400, proving that old letters can be worth big bucks.
10. A Man’s Life—Literally
In 2008, Australian man Ian Usher decided he needed a fresh start. So, he put his entire life up for sale on eBay. This wasn’t just a symbolic listing—he included his house, car, job, and even introductions to his friends. His unconventional auction ended at $384,000, which he used to travel the world.
11. A Flamin’ Hot Cheeto Shaped Like Harambe
The internet has a weird sense of humor, and nowhere was that clearer than when a Flamin’ Hot Cheeto resembling Harambe (the beloved gorilla who became a meme after his tragic demise) went up for sale. Bids skyrocketed, and the spicy snack ultimately sold for nearly $100,000.
12. A Vampire Killing Kit
For those who take their supernatural protection seriously, an antique vampire-killing kit was sold on eBay for over $12,000. It contained wooden stakes, a pistol, a crucifix, and other essentials for dealing with the undead. Hopefully, the buyer never had to put it to use.
13. A Brussels Sprout from Christmas Dinner
In 2005, someone in England listed a single Brussels sprout left over from their Christmas dinner. Instead of being tossed away like most holiday leftovers, it found a buyer willing to pay £99.50. The best part? The money went to charity.
14. A Dorito Shaped Like the Pope’s Hat
What do you do when you find a Dorito that looks like the Pope’s mitre (his ceremonial hat)? If you’re a creative eBay user, you sell it! While the exact price remains a mystery, it attracted plenty of attention from both snack enthusiasts and religious collectors alike.
15. A Time Machine
Someone once put a so-called time machine up for sale, claiming it could transport users through time. Whether it was a prop, a scam, or a true attempt at bending the laws of physics, bidders were intrigued. No word on whether the buyer ever made it to the future (or the past).
16. A Ghost Cane
A seller listed an old walking cane, claiming it was haunted by its former owner’s spirit. While some buyers scoffed at the supernatural claim, someone was willing to spend $65 on the eerie artifact. Whether the ghost actually followed remains unknown.
17. A Piece of the Moon
A seller once attempted to auction what they claimed was a genuine moon rock. While NASA prohibits the sale of lunar samples collected during space missions, the listing attracted significant interest before being removed.
18. A Wedding Dress with a Story
One of eBay’s most viral listings was a man selling his ex-wife’s wedding dress—complete with a brutally honest and humorous description of their failed marriage. The listing became an internet sensation, racking up bids and ultimately selling for over $3,000.
19. The Right to Name a Baby
One expectant mother decided to auction off the right to name her unborn child. The winning bidder paid $6,800 and chose the name “GoldenPalaceDotcom” after the online casino—a marketing stunt that ensured this child had one of the most unusual names ever.
Conclusion
eBay has always been a place where anything goes, and as this list proves, people will buy (and sell) just about anything. From ghostly jars to celebrity leftovers, the platform continues to be a digital treasure trove of the weird, the wild, and the wonderfully unexpected. If you have something strange, unique, or downright bizarre that you want to sell but don’t know where to start, Cleveland Wholesale Warehouse can help you navigate the process and turn your oddities into cash!
Views Expressed Disclaimer
The views, opinions, and information presented in this article are for informational purposes only and do not necessarily reflect the official policies or positions of Cleveland Wholesale Warehouse, LLC. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, Cleveland Wholesale Warehouse, LLC is not liable for any errors, omissions, or decisions made based on the content provided. Readers are encouraged to consult professionals for specific advice or assistance related to their unique circumstances.
